|Willner v Dept of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources (VSC) - freedom of information - artist sought CCTV film from train carriage to use in artwork - arguable error of law in refusing film - leave to appeal granted
|Miles v Campus Living Villages Murdock Pty Ltd (WASC) - tenant sought injunction against eviction - foreshadowed Supreme Court proceedings - injunction granted
|Summaries With Link (Five Minute Read)
|Willner v Dept of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources VSC 504
Freedom of information - the applicant is a photographer and artist whose artwork explores the boundaries of public space - he requested from the Department 24 hours of CCTV footage that had been recorded in a train carriage - he intended to use that footage in an artwork in a public exhibition - Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Vic) – deemed refusal - applicant applied to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal - Tribunal affirmed refusal on basis that release of the footage would involve the unreasonable disclosure of information relating to the personal affairs of any person - applicant sought leave to appeal to Supreme Court on questions of law - held: there was a real argument there had been an error of law - that is, it was arguable that the Tribunal's factual finding that pixelating the footage would be prohibitively expensive was not open on the evidence - leave to appeal granted.
|Miles v Campus Living Villages Murdock Pty Ltd  WASC 350
Supreme Court of Western Australia
Residential tenancy – student accommodation provider obtained orders against student tenant in Magistrates Court - tenant applied to Supreme Court for injunction against eviction - held: tenant originally sought injunction as a cause of action in and of itself, with no other cause of action or proceedings in the Court - Court's injunctive power is dependent on a pre-existing cause of action arising from an actual or threatened invasion of a legal or equitable right - during the hearing, tenant foreshadowed Supreme Court proceedings to review the Magistrates Court decision - alleged denial of natural justice due to non-service of notice of those proceedings - s36 Magistrates Court Act 2004 (WA) – foreshadowed proceedings gave the Court jurisdiction to make the injunction sought - there was a serious case to be tried in the foreshadowed proceedings - balance of convenience favoured granting the injunction - injunction granted on condition the tenant file the foreshadowed proceedings and give the usual undertaking as to damages.