A daily Bulletin listing our choice of Decisions of Superior Courts of Australia.

Weekly Insurance Law Review

Friday, 10 October 2014
Executive Summary (One Minute Read)
Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v Owners Corporation Strata Plan 61288 (HCA) - builder contracted with property developer - builder did not owe duty of care to Owners Corporation who succeeded developer in title
Jackson Lalic Lawyers Pty Ltd v Attwells (NSWCA) - negligence - erroneous refusal to answer separate question - solicitors' advice protected by advocates' immunity - appeal allowed
El Masri v Woolworths Ltd (NSWSC) - judicial review - no error in medical appeal panel's confirmation of assessment of worker's permanent impairment
Rankin v Gosford City Council (NSWSC) - negligence - motorcyclist injured in collision with traffic barriers moved by unknown malefactors - Council not liable
Moama Bowling Club Ltd v The Thomson Group Pty Ltd (VSCA) - negligence - fire at bowling club not caused by shattering globe - electrical contractor not liable
Sleeman v SPI Electricity Pty Ltd (VSCA) - statutory compensation - installation of electricity poles - owners of neighbouring land refused compensation
Fitzgerald v CBL Insurance Ltd (VSC) - insurance contract - claim by trustees under financial insurance policy - insolvency - rectification - proof of loss - damages
Liberty International Underwriters v The Salisbury Group Pty Ltd (in liq) (QSC) - professional indemnity insurance - beneficiary of discretionary trust sued by trustee for negligent financial advice - trustee sued in its own right as trustee, not on behalf of beneficiaries - exclusions did not apply
Hamcor Pty Ltd v Queensland (QSC) - negligence - chemical factory fire - contamination of land by water applied by fire brigade mixed with chemicals - claims against fire brigade and insurance brokers failed
Summaries With Link (Five Minute Read)
Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v Owners Corporation Strata Plan 61288 [2014] HCA 36
High Court of Australia
French CJ, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel, Bell, Gageler & Keane JJ
Negligence - builder contracted with property developer to build strata units - common property vested in Owners Corporation on registration of strata plan - latent defects in common property - Owners Corporation allegedly suffered economic loss - Owners Corporation sued builder in negligence - Owners Corporation failed before single judge of NSW Supreme Court, but succeeded in Court of Appeal - held: when strata plan registered, Owners Corporation came into existence and held common property as agent for developer and was effectively controlled by the developer - builder's responsibilities to developer were defined in detail by design and development contract - Owners Corporation and purchasers of lots were not vulnerable to builder in the required sense - builder owed no duty of care to the developer - builder owed no duty of care to the Owners Corporation - appeal allowed.
Brookfield Multiplex Ltd
[From Benchmark 9 October 2014]
Jackson Lalic Lawyers Pty Ltd v Attwells [2014] NSWCA 335
Court of Appeal of New South Wales
Bathurst CJ; Meagher & Ward JJA
Negligence - solicitors' duties - advocates' immunity - separate question - respondents claimed law firm gave negligent advice when representing them in guarantee proceedings - advice led to settlement of proceedings by consent - law firm appealed against primary judge's decision to decline to answer separate question whether advocates' immunity from suit was complete answer to negligence claim - held: primary judge erred in declining to answer separate question - reasons given for refusal to answer question were irrelevant - in circumstances where alleged breach was clearly defined and agreed upon it was appropriate to answer separate question - advice fell within scope of advocates' immunity as it led to guarantee proceedings being settled and was therefore intimately connected with those proceedings - negligence proceedings would involve re-agitation of issues in guarantee proceedings and would offend principle of finality - appeal allowed - judgment for law firm in negligence proceedings.
Jackson Lalic Lawyers Pty Ltd
[From Benchmark 3 October 2014]
El Masri v Woolworths Ltd [2014] NSWSC 1344
Supreme Court of New South Wales
Campbell J
Judicial review - workers compensation - worker employed by Woolworths as storeman and packer - worker sought compensation under s66 Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) for permanent impairment resulting from injury suffered at work - worker sought to quash decision of medical appeal panel confirming assessment of permanent impairment which fell short of threshold for purposes of claim for work injury damages - ss4, 9A, 66 & 151H Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) - ss319 & 320 Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (NSW) - held: no failure by medical panel to take into account doctor's evidence as to relationship between work and the deterioration of worker's condition - panel discharged its obligations in relation to provision of reasons - no constructive denial of jurisdiction - proceedings dismissed.
El Masri
[From Benchmark 3 October 2014]
Rankin v Gosford City Council [2014] NSWSC 1354
Supreme Court of New South Wales
Button J
Negligence - unknown malefactors moved traffic barriers hired by Council for use in road works - plaintiff injured when he collided with barriers while riding motorbike along road - ss5B, 5C, 5D, 5E & 45 Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) - s7(4) Roads Act 1993 (NSW) - s45E Transport Administration Act 1988 (NSW) - held: Council not protected by statutory immunity contained in s45 Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) - Council did not owe duty of care to forestall crimes of others that harmed plaintiff - judgment for Council.
[From Benchmark 7 October 2014]
Moama Bowling Club Ltd v The Thomson Group Pty Ltd [2014] VSCA 245
Court of Appeal of Victoria
Nettle, Tate & Beach JJA
Negligence - appellant's bowling club extensively damaged by fire - proprietor claimed fire caused by floodlight containing halogen lamp installed by electrical contractor and claimed damages in negligence from contractor - causation - Pt X, ss51 & 52 Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) - primary judge not satisfied fire initiated by globe in floodlight shattering - primary judge also held that, even if it were necessary to make finding whether contractor was negligent in selection, supply and fitting of floodlight, contractor was not negligent - primary judge dismissed proprietor's action - appellant contended primary judge erred by paying no or insufficient regard to various aspects of evidence - held: all grounds of appeal rejected - no error in decision of primary judge - appeal dismissed.
Moama Bowling Club Ltd
[From Benchmark 8 October 2014]
Sleeman v SPI Electricity Pty Ltd [2014] VSCA 243
Court of Appeal of Victoria
Nettle, Beach & Kyrou JJ
Statutory compensation - appellants were owners of land on which they proposed to build aerodrome - appellants sought compensation under s93(2) Electricity Industry Act 2000 (Vic) for decrease in value of land due to electricity corporation's installation of electricity poles on neighbouring land - any land - held: primary judge correct to hold compensation provisions in s93(2) were confined to the owner of land upon which an electricity corporation undertook authorised activities - appellants were not entitled to compensation under s 93(2) - appeal dismissed
[From Benchmark 8 October 2014]
Fitzgerald v CBL Insurance Ltd [2014] VSC 493
Supreme Court of Victoria
Sloss J
Insurance contract - insolvency - rectification - company procured insurer to issue financial insurance policy in favour of 'transferring employees' of businesses - under policy, insurer agreed to provide indemnity in respect of shortfall in 'employee entitlements' in event of insolvency of company - company placed in liquidation following administration - insolvency deemed to have taken place as at date of administration - trustees made claims and demands under policy - construction of policy - employee entitlements owed as at deemed date for purposes of insurance policy - whether provisions of certified agreements enlivened - whether employee's jobs were made redundant - whether rectification sought by insurer required continuing common intention - interest under s57 Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) - claim for damages to recover time and cost in managing claims - proof of loss - held: trustees proved fact of loss to which policy responded - primary claim made for insured loss represented shortfall for 336 transferring employees identified - Court not satisfied trustees made out claim for time and costs involved in preparing and managing the claim.
[From Benchmark 7 October 2014]
Liberty International Underwriters v The Salisbury Group Pty Ltd (in liq) [2014] QSC 240
Supreme Court of Queensland
Flanagan J
Insurance - equity - trusts and trustees - investment advice company held professional indemnity insurance policy - authorised representative of investment advice company also insured - investment advice company, through the authorised representative, gave financial advice to trustee of authorised representative's family trust - authorised representative and family were discretionary beneficiaries under trust - authorised representative's spouse and children were trustee's directors and shareholders - trustee sued investment advice company and authorised representative for negligent financial advice and misleading and deceptive conduct - investment advice company and authorised representative sought indemnity under policy - policy excluded cover for a claim made on behalf of one insured against another, or one insured's spouse or child against another insured - policy also excluded cover for claim made on behalf of any entity in which an insured had a financial interest - insurer declined indemnity - held: trustee had brought proceedings in its own right as trustee of trust, not on behalf of related entities or family member of insured against another insured - trustee did not have a financial interest in trust.
Liberty International Underwriters
[From Benchmark 9 October 2014]
Hamcor Pty Ltd v Queensland [2014] QSC 224
Supreme Court of Queensland
Dalton J
Negligence - fire in plaintiffs' chemical factory - water used by fire brigade to douse fire became mixed with chemicals and soaked onto plaintiffs' land contaminating it - cost of remediation accepted to be more than $9 million which was many times more than value of land - plaintiffs sued State in negligence for acts and omissions of fire brigade - plaintiffs' property insurers had paid plaintiffs full amount for which they were insured but refused to pay on policy in name of company which ran business of factory - plaintiffs sued insurance brokers who had arranged liability insurance for company for pure economic loss - held: State owed duty to plaintiffs to take reasonable care not to damage property when acting to combat fire and hazardous materials emergency on plaintiffs' land - fire brigade breached its duty to plaintiffs in applying large amounts of water to certain areas of the land - application of water fell within s129(1) Fire and Rescue Service Act 1990 (Qld) Act with consequence fire brigade had immunity - brokers owed no duty of care to plaintiffs - plaintiffs' alternative claims against brokers under s912A(1)(a) Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and s12ED(1)(a) Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) also failed - judgment for defendants.
Hamcor Pty Ltd
[From Benchmark 3 October 2014]

From "The Princess"
By Lord Alfred Tennyson

Come down, O maid, from yonder mountain height:
What pleasure lives in height (the shepherd sang),
In height and cold, the splendour of the hills?
But cease to move so near the Heavens, and cease
To glide a sunbeam by the blasted Pine,
To sit a star upon the sparkling spire;
And come, for Love is of the valley, come,
For Love is of the valley, come thou down
And find him; by the happy threshold, he,
Or hand in hand with Plenty in the maize,
Or red with spirted purple of the vats,
Or foxlike in the vine; nor cares to walk
With Death and Morning on the silver horns,
Nor wilt thou snare him in the white ravine,
Nor find him dropt upon the firths of ice,
That huddling slant in furrow-cloven falls
To roll the torrent out of dusky doors:
But follow; let the torrent dance thee down
To find him in the valley; let the wild
Lean-headed Eagles yelp alone, and leave
The monstrous ledges there to slope, and spill
Their thousand wreaths of dangling water-smoke
That like a broken purpose waste in air:
So waste not thou; but come; for all the vales
Await thee; azure pillars of the hearth
Arise to thee; the children call, and I
Thy shepherd pipe, and sweet is every sound,
Sweeter thy voice, but every sound is sweet;
Myriads of rivulets hurrying thro' the lawn,
The moan of doves is immemorial elms,
And murmuring of innumerable bees.

Lord Alfred Tennyson